What Not to Say When Buying a Car (From a Former Car Salesman)
For ten years I sat across the desk from buyers in Houston. The ones who paid the most weren't bad negotiators. They just said a few innocent-sounding things that told me exactly how to work the deal. Here are the 10 phrases I was always listening for, and what to say instead.
1. "I can afford about $500 a month."
This is the most expensive sentence in car buying. Give a payment and the dealer can stretch the loan to 84 months and make almost any price "fit."
Say instead: "I'm focused on the out-the-door price. We can talk payments after."
2. "I love this car."
Excitement is leverage, and it's not yours.
Say instead: "It's one of a few I'm considering."
3. "I need a car today."
Urgency kills your ability to walk away, which is your only real power.
Say instead: "I'm buying this month from whoever gives me the best written price."
4. "I have a trade-in" (too early)
Mention it up front and the dealer can move money between the new car and your trade to make either number look good.
Say instead: nothing, until the new car's price is agreed in writing. Get a CarMax or Carvana offer first so you know what it's worth.
5. "I'm paying cash" (too early)
Dealers often make money on financing. Announce cash early and the discount can shrink.
Say instead: "I haven't decided how I'll pay. Let's agree on the price first."
6. "What's your best price?"
You'll get a number with plenty of room left in it, and no detail.
Say instead: "Please send me an itemized out-the-door price in writing." Here's what that should include.
7. "My credit is bad."
Let the numbers speak. Volunteering this invites a higher rate.
Say instead: "I'm pre-approved through my credit union." Get the pre-approval first.
8. "Sure, I'll take the protection package."
Paint sealant, nitrogen, etching and "theft protection" are some of the highest-profit items in the building.
Say instead: "Please remove any add-ons I didn't ask for." See Texas fees you can refuse.
9. "Yes" in the finance office, out of tiredness
After three hours, saying yes to an extended warranty feels easier than another conversation.
Say instead: "No, thank you. I'll think about it and buy it later if I want it." Most products can be bought later, often for less.
10. "I'll just sign. I trust you."
Read every line. Compare the buyer's order to the written price you agreed on.
Say instead: "Give me a minute to check this against my quote."
Or don't say anything at all.
I do the talking, the emailing and the finance-office "no thank you" for you. $1,000 flat, with a $1,000 savings guarantee.